Energy transition from economic and environmental perspectives

Energy transition changes how we produce, deliver and use energy. Economically, the question is how much we pay for reliable building heating, factory operations or transport. Environmentally, what matters is the fuel and raw materials consumed, the emissions produced and where their impacts are felt. The most valuable measures maintain the same quality and continuity of operations while reducing energy use, costs and environmental burdens.
The economics of transition. What does delivering energy really cost?
For a business, the price of one megawatt-hour is only part of the bill. Replacing a heat source may reduce fuel use while increasing expenditure on connection capacity, maintenance or backup supply. Investment options should therefore be compared at the same temperature, ventilation rate and production volume. If a plant heated a hall to 15°C before modernisation but must maintain 18°C afterwards, comparing bills alone combines two effects: the change in technology and the increase in temperature.
At national level, the distinction between generating electricity and ensuring supply in every hour is similarly important. Wind and solar produce energy without buying fuel, but their output depends on weather. The value of another installation therefore also depends on whether the grid can accept its output and whether customers need it at that hour. The assessment includes investment in grids, storage, dispatchable generation and demand management. Sometimes shifting equipment operation or heating a water tank earlier is a cheaper way to reduce peak demand.
Transition also affects price risk. A plant using less gas is less exposed to increases in its price. If some gas is replaced with electricity, the structure of that risk changes. Electricity prices, tariffs, consumption hours and contract terms become important. Investment should therefore be assessed under several price scenarios, each accounting for capital expenditure, operating costs and expected equipment life.
The environmental side of transition. Climate, health and resource use
Reducing fossil fuel combustion can lower CO₂ emissions and improve local air quality. These are two distinct effects. CO₂ affects the climate, while particulate matter, sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides affect the air people breathe. The European Environment Agency reported that emissions of sulphur dioxide and dust from large combustion plants in the EU fell by more than 94% between 2004 and 2024. Stricter requirements, flue-gas treatment and changes in the fuel mix all contributed.
A sound environmental assessment also considers the installation’s entire life cycle. Building a power station, energy store or grid requires materials and land. Location, impacts on water and biodiversity, equipment durability and material recovery at end of life all matter. When heating or production is electrified, it is also worth calculating the emissions removed from the plant itself and those associated with additional electricity drawn from the grid.
Energy efficiency matters from both perspectives. If producing a tonne of product requires less energy, the company pays less per unit and the system must meet lower demand. In practice, this may involve recovering refrigeration heat, repairing compressed-air leaks or changing the controls of equipment that runs during production breaks.
One plant, two accounts. Costs and emissions after heat recovery
Assume a plant uses heat from refrigeration to warm process water. It consequently consumes 300 MWh less gas per year, while pumps and auxiliary equipment use an additional 40 MWh of electricity. The investment costs PLN 270,000 net and additional maintenance PLN 6,000 a year. The following model prices cover consumption-dependent costs.
| Item | Base scenario | Lower gas price and higher electricity price scenario |
|---|---|---|
| Net gas price | PLN 250/MWh | PLN 200/MWh |
| Net electricity price | PLN 600/MWh | PLN 750/MWh |
| Annual saving after electricity and maintenance | PLN 45,000 | PLN 24,000 |
| Simple payback period | 6 years | 11.3 years |
| Net present value over 15 years at an 8% discount rate | +PLN 115,000 | −PLN 65,000 |

Net present value includes the initial investment and converts future savings into today’s money. The model assumes constant real prices and savings each year. A positive result in the base scenario and a negative result in the second show how strongly the gas-to-electricity price relationship affects the investment decision.
The environmental account can be calculated separately. At a gas emissions factor of 0.202 t CO₂/MWh on a net calorific value basis, reduced combustion avoids about 60.6 t CO₂ a year. Using KOBiZE’s 2024 end-user electricity factor of 0.553 t CO₂/MWh, the extra electricity represents about 22.1 t CO₂. The operational balance is therefore about 38.5 t CO₂ less per year, estimated using an average national electricity factor. A full environmental assessment would also cover equipment manufacture and end-of-life treatment. Gas consumption must use the same energy basis as the emissions factor.
The Polish perspective. Who bears the costs, and when do benefits appear?
In 2025, public hard-coal and lignite power stations generated about 102 TWh out of the 166.5 TWh of domestic electricity production recorded by PSE. At this scale, investment sequencing matters. New generation, grids and demand flexibility must develop at a pace that maintains reliability as older units retire. Costs often arise upfront, while fuel savings and environmental benefits accrue over years.
Economic impacts also depend on location. Lower coal use may improve air quality in many communities, while job losses and declining local revenues concentrate in particular regions. Investment in new jobs, worker skills and local businesses therefore matters. Households face a similar issue in access to capital. Insulating a building can reduce future bills but requires money today. The national balance and the position of an individual family or municipality require separate assessments.
For a business, three measured figures provide a useful test after implementation: energy used per unit of product, the cost of that energy and emissions per unit. Comparing these with pre-investment operating conditions shows whether the expected benefits have materialised and which modernisation should come next.
Sources and further reading
- IEA — Energy Efficiency 2025
- IPCC — AR6 Synthesis Report
- UNECE — Life Cycle Assessment of Electricity Generation Options
- URE — efektywność energetyczna
- IEA — Electricity Grids and Secure Energy Transitions
- IEA — The Future of Heat Pumps
- EEA — Emissions and energy use in large combustion plants in Europe
- WHO — Ambient air pollution and health
- GHG Protocol — Scope 2 Guidance
- IPCC — 2006 Guidelines, Energy
- KOBiZE — wskaźniki emisyjności energii elektrycznej za 2024 r.
- PSE — Raport za 2025 r.
- European Commission — Just Transition Mechanism
- European Commission — Energy poverty
