CKTEEnergy Transformation
Competence Centre
Explore the opportunities ↗
← CKTE publications
KNOWLEDGE / ENERGY TRANSFORMATION

RED I and RED II Directives

Conceptual view of a business with rooftop photovoltaics, industrial heat pumps and distant wind turbines
Conceptual illustration prepared for this publication and generated digitally.

A company installing rooftop photovoltaics on its factory, replacing a gas boiler with a heat pump or buying energy directly from a renewable generator operates in a market shaped by RED I and RED II. The first directive set national renewable energy development targets. The second strengthened the position of consumers wishing to generate, store or buy renewable energy themselves. For businesses, the opportunity is less dependence on fuel and grid electricity prices. Financial performance nevertheless depends on how much energy the company actually uses and what it pays to have it delivered.

What did RED I and RED II introduce?

RED I, Directive 2009/28/EC, set a target of 20% renewable energy in the EU’s gross final energy consumption by 2020. Member States received different binding targets. Poland’s target was 15%, under Article 3(1) and Annex I, Part A. Separately, Article 3(4) set each country a target of at least 10% renewable energy in transport in 2020, calculated using the directive’s methodology. RED I also established rules for electricity guarantees of origin (Article 15) and renewable energy access to the grid (Article 16).

RED II, Directive (EU) 2018/2001, originally established a common EU target of at least 32% for 2030 (Article 3(1)). It introduced a framework for renewable self-consumers to generate, consume, store and sell renewable electricity (Article 21), and for renewable energy communities (Article 22). It also addressed renewables in heating and cooling (Article 23), originally envisaged a 14% renewable energy share in transport by 2030 (Article 25(1)), and defined sustainability and greenhouse gas emissions saving criteria for biofuels, bioliquids and biomass fuels (Article 29).

[1] [2]

Implementation dates and legal bases

Implementation dates and legal bases
DateWhat changed and the relevant provision
23 April 2009RED I was adopted. It was published on 5 June 2009 and entered into force on 25 June 2009 under Article 28.
30 June and 5 December 2010Member States had to submit national renewable energy action plans to the Commission by 30 June (RED I, Article 4(2)). National transposition was due by 5 December (Article 27(1)).
20 February 2015Poland adopted its Renewable Energy Sources Act (Journal of Laws 2015, item 478), implementing RED I within its scope.
11 December 2018RED II was adopted. It was published on 21 December 2018 and entered into force on 24 December 2018 under Article 38.
30 June and 1 July 2021The principal RED II transposition deadline expired on 30 June (Article 36(1)). RED I was repealed on 1 July under Article 37 of RED II.
17 August 2023Poland adopted an amendment to its Renewable Energy Sources Act to implement RED II (Journal of Laws 2023, item 1762). Most provisions entered into force on 1 October 2023, with separate dates for some changes.
20 November 2023RED III, Directive (EU) 2023/2413 of 18 October 2023 amending RED II, entered into force. Article 5 set a transposition deadline of 21 May 2025, and 1 July 2024 for certain permitting provisions.

[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]

Which targets apply today?

Following RED III amendments, Article 3(1) of Directive 2018/2001 sets a binding EU-wide renewable energy target of at least 42.5% for 2030, with a collective endeavour to reach 45%. Amended Article 25(1) gives Member States a transport choice between at least 29% renewable energy and a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions intensity of at least 14.5% by 2030. Amended Article 23(1) also sets a minimum average annual increase in the renewable share of heating and cooling, including 1.1 percentage points in 2026–2030.

In its updated National Energy and Climate Plan, assessed by the Commission on 13 November 2026, Poland indicated 32% renewables in gross final energy consumption in 2030 as its national contribution to the EU target. The original EU-wide 32% target under RED II should therefore be distinguished from Poland’s 32% contribution in its national plan. A specific company’s obligations follow from the rules applicable to its activities, installations and energy settlement arrangements.

[2] [3] [7] [8]

Benefits and risks for businesses

One benefit is the ability to reduce energy and fuel purchases. A factory operating mainly during the day can use some of its own photovoltaic electricity directly in production. A large electricity consumer can consider a long-term power purchase agreement with a renewable generator, or PPA, defining price and volume settlement terms. Guarantees of origin, governed by Article 19 of RED II and Article 120 of Poland’s Renewable Energy Sources Act, document energy origin. Across the economy, renewables accounted for approximately 22% in the EU and 16.1% in Poland in 2020, above the overall targets for that year.

The main risk is an investment poorly matched to factory operations. Oversized photovoltaics increase exports to the grid at times when selling prices may be low. Limited connection capacity can delay an investment or change its scope. In heating, a high supply temperature can reduce a heat pump’s seasonal performance and consume expected savings. Biomass and biogas economics also depend on fuel availability, quality and the documentation required to demonstrate compliance with Articles 29–30 of RED II as amended.

[2] [4] [9] [10] [11]

Example: how much does heat pump performance change the bill?

A factory needs 300 MWh of useful heat annually. The assumptions are 90% seasonal boiler efficiency, PLN 300 net/MWh for gas and PLN 700 net/MWh for electricity. These are model assumptions for consumption-dependent costs. Each option provides the same amount of useful heat.

Example: how much does heat pump performance change the bill?
OptionAnnual purchased energy consumptionAnnual energy costChange compared with the boiler
Gas boiler, 90% efficiency333.3 MWh gasPLN 100,000—
Heat pump, SPF 2.0150 MWh electricityPLN 105,000PLN 5,000 more
Heat pump, SPF 3.0100 MWh electricityPLN 70,000PLN 30,000 less
Heat pump, SPF 4.075 MWh electricityPLN 52,500PLN 47,500 less
Modelled annual energy costs for 300 MWh of heat: gas boiler PLN 100,000; heat pump SPF 2.0 PLN 105,000, SPF 3.0 PLN 70,000, SPF 4.0 PLN 52,500
COMPARISON / 300 MWh OF USEFUL HEATChart created exclusively for this publication. Assumptions: gas PLN 300 net/MWh, electricity PLN 700 net/MWh, boiler efficiency 90%. Consumption-dependent costs; capital expenditure, maintenance and fixed charges excluded.

At these prices, energy-only costs are equal at an SPF of 2.1. Here, SPF means heat delivered over the whole season per unit of electricity consumed. At SPF 3.0, the pump supplies 300 MWh of heat, consumes 100 MWh of electricity and extracts around 200 MWh from the environment. This last amount can count as renewable energy if the conditions in Article 7(4) and Annex VII of RED II are met. A full investment assessment should additionally include capital expenditure, maintenance, fixed charges and any connection upgrade.

[2]

How can a company use RED and reduce risk?

  1. Measure consumption profiles before sizing the installation. Analyse hourly or 15-minute electricity data. For heat, establish the energy needed for space heating, hot water and production processes, and the temperature required by each recipient.
  2. Assess heat recovery before purchasing a new source. Heat from refrigeration, compressors or processes can replace some purchased fuel. Results depend on available temperature, operating hours and coincidence with demand. In the energy balance, show recovered waste heat separately from renewable energy qualifying under the directive.
  3. Check the connection and value self-consumption and surpluses separately. Agree available connection conditions with the network operator before ordering. In a photovoltaic model, value energy used on site at the avoided purchase cost and exported electricity according to its sale terms.
  4. Compare options at the same output and working conditions. For a heat pump, check performance at the actual supply temperature. For a PPA, analyse price, delivery profile, shortfall and surplus settlement, and transfer of guarantees of origin. For biomass and biogas, check fuel supplies and the required evidence of origin and compliance.

Before signing a contract, management should know annual energy costs under several price scenarios and the cost per unit of product after the upgrade. It can then assess whether the investment remains profitable in a year with lower production, more expensive electricity or lower surplus sale prices.

[2] [11]

Sources and legal bases

  1. Directive 2009/28/EC — RED I (historical act)
  2. Directive (EU) 2018/2001 — RED II and consolidated texts
  3. Directive (EU) 2023/2413 — RED III, amendments to RED II
  4. Polish Renewable Energy Sources Act of 20 February 2015
  5. Amendment of 17 August 2023 — Journal of Laws 2023, item 1762
  6. European Commission — Renewable Energy Directive
  7. European Commission — assessment of Poland’s NECP, 13 November 2026
  8. European Commission — detailed assessment of Poland’s NECP, SWD(2026) 345
  9. Eurostat — share of energy from renewable sources
  10. Statistics Poland — renewable energy in 2020
  11. URE — connecting generation to the electricity grid
PUBLICATION AUTHORJakub Touściuk
All publications ←