ETS I, ETS II

Legal position as at 15 November 2026
A Polish business using gas to heat its premises, electricity for production and diesel for transport may encounter carbon costs on several bills. ETS I already affects the cost of generating electricity and heat. From 2028, ETS II will cover emissions from fuel combustion in buildings, road transport and other sectors. Businesses therefore need to calculate how fuel price increases will affect margins and where consumption can be reduced without compromising working conditions or production.
How do ETS I and ETS II work?
ETS I is the EU emissions trading system operating since 2005. It covers power and heating plants, installations in industries including steel, cement and refining, and parts of aviation and maritime transport. The EU sets a declining allowance cap, while the market determines the price. Covered operators surrender allowances corresponding to their verified emissions. Carbon costs may also affect the prices of electricity, heat and materials sold to companies outside ETS I. The legal basis includes Article 2 and Annex I, and Articles 9, 12, 14 and 15 of Directive 2003/87/EC.
ETS II has a separate allowance pool and its own market price. It covers CO₂ from fuel combustion in buildings, road transport and additional sectors, including parts of industry outside ETS I. Entities releasing covered fuels for consumption, usually fuel suppliers, are responsible for monitoring and surrendering allowances. A typical shop, hotel, factory or transport company will primarily feel ETS II when its supplier includes allowance costs in gas, heating oil or road fuel prices. This follows from Articles 30a–30f and Annex III of Directive 2003/87/EC, introduced by Directive (EU) 2023/959.
Implementation dates and specific legal bases
| Date | What changes and the relevant provision |
|---|---|
| 13 October 2003 | Directive 2003/87/EC establishing ETS I was adopted. Its original Article 11(1) set the first trading period for 2005–2007. |
| 1 January 2005 | ETS I began operating. Poland’s first implementing act, dated 22 December 2004 (Journal of Laws No 281, item 2784), entered into force on the same day. |
| 10 May 2023 | Directive (EU) 2023/959 was adopted. Article 1(29) added Chapter IVa establishing ETS II. Under Article 3(1), the principal national transposition deadline was 30 June 2024. Separate Directive (EU) 2023/958 of the same date amended ETS I rules for aviation. |
| 1 January 2025 | The EU timetable provided for the start of permitting and monitoring for ETS II regulated entities. The relevant provisions are Articles 30b(1) and 30f of Directive 2003/87/EC. |
| 11 March 2026 | Regulation (EU) 2026/667 was adopted and entered into force on 7 April 2026. Article 2 postpones the start of trading in ETS II sectors until 2028 and refers to Article 30k(2)(a)–(e) of the Directive. The original timetable envisaged 2027. |
| January 2027 | The Commission envisages the first early ETS II allowance auctions. The legal basis is Article 8(5) of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2830, amended by Regulation (EU) 2026/787. |
| 2028 → 31 May 2029 | 2028 will be the first year of emissions subject to ETS II surrender obligations. Regulated entities will first surrender allowances for these emissions by 31 May 2029. This follows from Article 30e(2), read with Article 30k(2)(d) of Directive 2003/87/EC and Article 2 of Regulation (EU) 2026/667. |
In Poland, the operating ETS I framework is set out in the Act of 12 June 2015 on greenhouse gas emissions allowance trading (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2026, item 1421). Relevant provisions for installation operators include Article 51 on permits, Article 84 on report verification and Article 92 on allowance surrender. In autumn 2026, the Polish government informed the Sejm about further negotiations on ETS II implementation conditions. For corporate budgets, the reference date remains 2028 as established in EU law.
Benefits and risks for the economy
The declining allowance pool gives businesses an economic incentive to reduce emissions. Recovering heat from a production process saves fuel and reduces exposure to fuel prices. Auction revenues finance the Modernisation Fund and Innovation Fund, among other instruments. According to the European Commission, emissions in ETS I sectors have fallen by approximately half since the system began. This is an observed result across those sectors during the system’s operation; technological and energy mix changes also contributed.
The greatest risk for businesses is several costs rising at once. A factory may pay more for heating and process gas, a carrier may increase rates, and a materials supplier may incorporate higher energy costs into its prices. A low-margin business selling under fixed-price contracts may feel this change before it can renegotiate its agreements. Energy-intensive industry also faces competitiveness risks when carbon costs rise faster than plants can modernise.
Budgets should also account for allowance price volatility. EUR 45 per tonne of CO₂ in 2020 prices is the intervention threshold in Article 30h(2) of Directive 2003/87/EC. Once the conditions are met, additional allowances enter the market, but their price may still exceed that threshold. Decision (EU) 2026/2402, entering into force on 17 November 2026, strengthens this mechanism by increasing the quantity released through this intervention from 20 million to 40 million allowances.
How much could ETS II cost? A factory example
A factory consumes 500 MWh of natural gas annually, measured on a net calorific value basis. Using an indicative factor of 0.20 t CO₂/MWh gives approximately 100 t CO₂ per year. The scenarios below assume an exchange rate of PLN 4.30/EUR and full pass-through of the allowance cost alone by the supplier. Amounts exclude VAT; allowance prices are assumptions for a sensitivity analysis.
| Assumed ETS II allowance price | Additional cost per MWh of gas | Additional annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| EUR 50/t CO₂ | PLN 43.00 | PLN 21,500 |
| EUR 80/t CO₂ | PLN 68.80 | PLN 34,400 |
| EUR 120/t CO₂ | PLN 103.20 | PLN 51,600 |

If the factory reduces gas consumption by 25%, at EUR 80/t CO₂ it cuts the modelled ETS II cost by PLN 8,600 annually. It also saves the purchase cost of 125 MWh of gas. For company-specific calculations, billed consumption and the emission factor must use the same energy basis: gas bills may use gross calorific value, while this example’s factor uses net calorific value.
How can a business reduce the impact of ETS?
- Calculate the cost per unit of activity. Collect at least 12 months of gas, electricity and fuel consumption data. Separate heating, processes and transport. Express the ETS impact in PLN per tonne of product, kilometre travelled or square metre of premises. This reveals which contracts and facilities are most exposed to increases.
- Start with losses and heat recovery. Check heating and ventilation schedules, insulation and heat available from refrigeration, compressors or production processes. Recovery is valuable when the source and recipient operate at similar times and the available temperature meets needs such as hot water, process cleaning or space heating.
- Compare upgrades delivering the same useful outcome. Assess a boiler, heat pump and hybrid system against the same indoor temperature, ventilation and production volume. For an electric option, include actual seasonal efficiency, supply temperature, connection capacity and the full electricity cost. Three scenarios for gas, electricity and allowance prices show which assumptions make the investment viable.
- Check contracts and settlement rules. Ask the fuel supplier how and when it will charge ETS II costs. Check transport contracts for fuel surcharge indexation and whether charges can be passed on to customers. An ETS I installation should also agree how to document fuel use with its supplier to avoid double counting emissions. Article 30f(5) of Directive 2003/87/EC addresses this issue.
- Verify financing before ordering equipment. In Poland, check white certificate conditions, current BGK calls and NFOŚiGW programmes. Social Climate Fund support has defined beneficiaries, including vulnerable micro-enterprises within Article 2(11) of Regulation (EU) 2023/955. Assess project economics at full investment cost and treat confirmed support as a separate scenario.
In 2027, businesses may obtain their first ETS II auction reference price. By then, a company can already know the cost of each additional PLN per MWh of fuel and which investments reduce consumption while maintaining required working conditions. This balance supports modernisation decisions with quantified savings and shows how much margin they protect when energy becomes more expensive.
Sources and legal bases
- Directive 2003/87/EC — ETS I and Chapter IVa (ETS II)
- Directive (EU) 2023/959 — ETS reform and establishment of ETS II
- Regulation (EU) 2026/667 — Article 2: ETS II postponement
- Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/787 — auctions
- Decision (EU) 2026/2402 — market stability reserve
- Polish Act — consolidated text, Journal of Laws 2026, item 1421
- European Commission — 2027 ETS I and ETS II auction calendars
- European Commission — ETS II system
- Regulation (EU) 2023/955 — Social Climate Fund
- IPCC — inventory guidelines, energy
- URE — energy efficiency and white certificates
- BGK — business financing
- NFOŚiGW — financing programmes
